The best of the Extended Stays. Clean, safe, friendly vibe with good parking and an unexpectedly beautiful view. Room had a strange sound and uncomfortable bed, but overall experience was pleasant. Quiet, secure, and ideal if you're visiting the mall.

Room #1 was a horror show: no bedding, uncleaned, visibly abandoned. Room #2 was better, but not great — uncomfortable bed, light leaks through curtains, noise from neighbors. Great service, but the experience didn’t redeem the stay.

Solid emergency stay with quick access to the mall. Rooms have kitchens but feel a bit run-down. No soundproofing, weird bathroom setup, and average comfort — but for $121 during a storm? Worth it. Book online only and double-check the address!

A budget-friendly, quirky hotel with mismatched décor and questionable vibes — but the bed was shockingly comfortable. Definitely a risk, but we slept well. Good parking lot visibility from the room. Conveniently located near the mall but rough around the edges.

Gorgeous hotel with confusing pay-to-park signage that caught us off guard. The concierge helped us avoid the fee for one night, but we likely won’t risk it again. Room was lovely but small, with a queen bed that felt tight. Not much stood out beyond the aesthetic.

A surprisingly spacious, comfortable hotel with some Wi-Fi quirks and AC inconsistencies depending on the room. Huge king suite with a living room, comfy pillows, blackout curtains (sometimes sticky), and a delightful waffle breakfast. One of our top 5 picks for hotels near American Dream.

Despite its name, this hotel is not in NYC. It offers nice common spaces but underdelivers on room experience. Confusing parking, lackluster breakfast, and a dead TV remote made the stay forgettable. Okay for a quick stay but not one we’d return to.

Aloft Meadowlands wowed us with its hip, upscale vibe and surprisingly affordable luxury. Our first-ever hotel date night was a hit: modern layout, cozy bed, stylish bathroom with sliding mirror doors, and Netflix-ready TV. The vibe is unforgettable. Within driving distance of the American Dream Mall and plenty of dining options.